Broadway Pizzeria Menu (Update 2026)

Broadway Pizzeria offers a menu packed with mouthwatering selections that tantalize taste buds. Begin with their renowned muffaletta and wood-fired pizza. The chicken alfredo pasta complements the pizza selection beautifully. Don't overlook their garlic knots—these chewy delights are a community favorite. Make your meal more exciting with a variety of subs and wings. Their cheese bread is a perfect starter for sharing. For the healthy eaters, try one of their fresh salads.

Specials include great deals like two 14" two-topping pizzas or a specialty pizza paired with cheese sticks.

For those feeling creative, build your own pizza or calzone. With a total of 41 dishes on the menu, every visit to Broadway Pizzeria promises something new to explore. You can’t forget to leave room for dessert, especially their New York cheesecake. No matter the craving, Broadway Pizzeria meets it with flair.

Broadway Pizzeria Menu image 1
Broadway Pizzeria Menu image 2
Broadway Pizzeria

Broadway Pizzeria Interior, Food, Ambiance

Stepping into Broadway Pizzeria, the ambiance draws you in with a cozy, inviting vibe. The space combines modern design elements with rustic touches, reflecting the warmth of an Italian trattoria. The open kitchen concept showcases the wood-fired oven, creating an interactive dining experience where guests can watch as their meals come to life.

The lively atmosphere buzzes with the sound of laughter, friendly chatter, and the aromas of roasting pizzas. Bright murals pay homage to the art of pizza-making, creating a community-friendly space perfect for families and friends. The attention to comfort extends to the seating arrangements, making it an ideal spot for both casual meals and celebratory gatherings. This is more than just a restaurant; it's a place where good food and great memories come together.

Broadway Pizzeria

About Broadway Pizzeria Food and Specialties

Broadway Pizzeria stands out for its impressive range of specialty pizzas that thrill diners. Try the Manhattan Pizza for a taste of New York or the Barbeque Chicken Pizza for a southern twist. Buffalo Chicken Pizza adds a spicy kick that's beloved by heat seekers. For lovers of subs, the variety of wood-fired hoagies pairs beautifully with any meal. Each dish highlights fresh ingredients sourced locally, ensuring quality in every bite.

Their specialties also include build-your-own options that allow diners to craft the perfect meal tailored to their preferences.

From the sauces to the toppings, every choice makes for a unique dining experience. This commitment to customization delights the everyday diner and special occasion celebrations alike. Every dish feels like a personal invitation to indulge in the delicious offerings.

Broadway Pizzeria

Broadway Pizzeria remains committed to serving quality food that brings people together. The vision focuses on celebrating traditional Italian flavors while embracing local ingredients whenever possible. Each dish is crafted with care, from the wood-fired pizzas to the flavorful pastas, ensuring an unforgettable dining experience. The specialty pizzas not only highlight distinct flavor profiles but also represent the culinary creativity that fuels this pizzeria. By fostering relationships within the community and often participating in local events, Broadway Pizzeria enhances its connection with Tuscaloosa’s residents. This dedication goes beyond food; it’s about creating a gathering place where memories are made over shared meals.